Kristin Cavallari Played ‘Fuck, Marry, Kill’ With Exes Stephen Colletti, Brody Jenner & Justin Bobby

The hardest decision of all time: choosing between the good-looking dudes from ‘Laguna Beach’ and ‘The Hills’.

Kristin Cavallari is all for kissing and telling when it comes to her former co-stars, and we’re absolutely here for it on a Tuesday afternoon. 

During a wine-fuelled Q&A session on Instagram Live with her best guy mate, Justin Anderson, last Thursday (Thanksgiving in the US), Kristin didn’t skip a beat when she was asked who among her The Hills exes she thought was the best kisser.

“Stephen Colletti!” she announced. Stephen, of course, being her ex from high school and co-star on Laguna Beach, as well as her co-subject in a recent reunion pic she shared to Instagram weeks after announcing her split from husband Jay Cutler. 

(We’re also pretty sure Stephen’s single at the moment, and Kristin still seems to be, too... Just throwing that out there.)

Stephen’s name came up again when Kristin was asked who she would fuck, marry or kill among her exes Stephen Colletti, Brody Jenner and Justin Bobby. (The hardest decision I could possibly imagine, if I’m honest.) “I would marry Stephen and I would fuck Brody and I would probably kill Justin Bobby,” she said. “No hard feelings! Only because I haven’t talked to him since The Hills.” Fair enough, I suppose.

Also in the session, Kristin was asked who she’d rather get stuck in a room with, Lauren Conrad or Kelly Henderson. Juicy question because Lauren Conrad was Kristin’s Laguna Beach co-star and kinda-rival..? While Kelly Henderson is Kristin’s ex-BFF who she had a falling out with a few years ago, after rumours came out that Kelly and Jay Cutler had hooked up. Kristin later said that she never thought the two had actually gotten together, but still, she and Kelly apparently no longer talk.

Kristin’s answer to the question? She simply sipped some wine before quickly changing the subject. Damn!

Here’s to Kristin spilling more goss and helping us get through these last few weeks of 2020. Thanks gal, we owe you. 

Written by Sangeeta Kocharekar, an American-born, Sydney-based writer at MTV. Photos from her pre-COVID-19 days as a travel writer are here.

More Good Stuff: 

Latest News